The congregation remained in this building for only one year. In 1972, the boiler, which provided heat for the building, exploded, destroying the fellowship hall. Despite this setback, the members moved to a new location on Eagle Street. Emmanuel Baptist Church, which was relocating, sold its building to St. James A.M.E. Church for the sum of one dollar ($1.00), including fixtures, the organ, hymnals, and stained glass.
Because the building was large and the congregation small, maintaining it proved difficult. Eventually, the doors closed on Eagle Street. Yet the congregation was again blessed with a new opportunity. In 1994, Plymouth Bethesda United Church of Christ invited the members of St. James to share their facilities for worship, a kindness for which the congregation remains deeply grateful.
The road has not been easy for St. James. The flood has come, and the torrent has struck the house, yet St. James has stood because it is built on the solid foundation of Jesus Christ. God has been faithful, meeting every need. The congregation stands fully persuaded that He who has begun a good work will bring it to completion.