Grace Community A.M.E. Church was founded around the year 2000 by Rev. Pedro Castro at the State University of New York at Buffalo, gathering in the Student Union Chapel.
That same year, the congregation was received into the Western New York Annual Conference. Early leadership included Trustee Greg Merrill and Karen Stubblefield, who served as Director of the Board of Christian Education.
From its beginning, Grace Community represented an effort to establish an A.M.E. presence within a university setting—meeting students and community members in a space shaped by learning, transition, and formation.