Bethel A.M.E. Church, Olean

---

Bethel A.M.E. Church of Olean was organized in 1876. A preacher by the name of Van Zaudt came to Olean with the intention of organizing a church. Though his direct involvement was limited, his presence helped spark the effort.

The local African American community came together, elected a board of trustees, and secured the assistance of Presiding Elder Collins of Elmira, who formally organized the church. Joseph Thomson was appointed as local preacher. The first trustees were T. J. Palmer (President), G. G. Peterson, and Edward Bonner.

In the years that followed, the trustees purchased a lot at the corner of State and Fifth Streets in Olean and erected a wooden church building measuring 28 by 40 feet. This structure was dedicated as a house of worship under the supervision of Presiding Elder Collins.

The early years of Bethel were marked by a succession of pastors and steady, if at times fragile, growth. Among those who served were William George of New Jersey, Rev. Mines of Oswego, Bro. Aldridge, Bro. Addison, Bro. Jackson, Bro. Cole, and Bro. William Chase. The church also received visits from Bishop Turner, reflecting its connection to the wider A.M.E. Church.

In 1890, Bro. Woodruff Post of Olean, a white minister, was called to serve the congregation after a period in which the church had remained unused. Under his leadership, the building was enlarged and improved, and the congregation regained stability. At the conclusion of his three-year pastorate, the church was placed within the Pittsburgh A.M.E. Conference.

Subsequent pastors included Bro. Benjamin Morgan (1893–1894), Bro. G. D. Skinner (1895–1896), and Bro. J. D. K. Memis, who served when Olean became part of a circuit. Bro. Eli McKnight followed, continuing the work for a period of two years.

In 1899, the church and all of its contents were destroyed by fire. The following year, under the leadership of Bishop Lee, the congregation was transferred to the New York Conference, and Bro. Lane was appointed as pastor, marking another transition in the life of the church.

Despite moments of renewal, the 20th century proved challenging for Bethel A.M.E. Church of Olean. The congregation struggled to sustain its earlier momentum, and over time its presence diminished.

Around 2004 or 2005, Bethel A.M.E. Church of Olean closed its doors. The final pastors to serve the congregation were Rev. Rosalind B. Baugh and Rev. Troy Carr.

Though no longer active, Bethel’s history remains a testimony to a people who gathered, built, rebuilt, and persisted in faith across generations.